Some people don't know how to pick their fights.
Today's Don Quixote is Alabama Chief Justice Roy Moore, whose defiance of the federal courts over that Ten Commandments monument at the courthouse is, for some people, big news. It must be, because it's leading the news at CNN and Fox. Very controversial, very important.
OK, not important. Controversial but not important.
Let's first note that the actual contents of the Ten Commandments aren't terribly controversial. I'm God, no blaspheming, show up for church, respect your parents, no murder, no adultery, don't steal, don't gossip, don't do your neighbor's wife, don't get all jealous and stuff over material crap. Pretty benign, and you can kinda ignore the first three if you're an atheist. Not a bad set of rules, nothing that should freak anyone out.
Then, let's note that it IS religion, and it's kinda unseemly to stick religion into a public place, constitution or no constitution. If you're Christian, you wouldn't want a monument to Allah there. You get the idea.
Finally, the most critical element to your understanding of the complex issues behind this case: it doesn't matter.
The monument's existence doesn't affect the jurisprudence in the courthouse, not any more than the bibles used for swearing in witnesses affect it. It's just... there. On the other hand, if it's removed, it won't change the jurisprudence, either. The monument doesn't change anything by its presence, and it doesn't remove anything by its absence. It just is.
So I see people, including the Chief Justice, ready to go to prison rather than allow the thing to be removed. I see people treating the ruling as a major victory for their interests. And I see a total loss of perspective. Ask yourself this: in what way does the existence or removal of that monument change the course of your- anybody's- life?
It doesn't.
And that's not to say that the commandments themselves don't matter- they do- or that some of the people passing through couldn't use a dose of Thou Shalt Not in their lives- they do. But they're not gonna get that from a monument. It's not the Bible, folks. It's just a monument. Take it away, leave it, carry it around like the Stanley Cup, whatever you want- just don't bother me about it. I have more important things on which to spend my energy, like the new Bullwinkle DVD. Hey, you have your religion, I have mine.
Share