I really shouldn't read the tech blogs anymore. Oh, that's not really quite the right way to put it. What I shouldn't be reading is the comments attached to the blog posts at places like Engadget and Gizmodo.
Here's what I mean: I wanted to see what people thought of the new version of Android, Ice Cream Sandwich. It was unveiled tonight (actually, early tomorrow Hong Kong time) along with the new Galaxy Nexus phone, and before the announcement, it was being touted as revolutionary, just like Apple tried to sell Siri as revolutionary a couple of short weeks ago. Of course, neither one is exactly revolutionary, at least not yet, but they're interesting, and I wanted to see what the new features would be. Now, I just bought an iPhone 4S, so I'm not in the market for new phone at the moment. But I'm also not an Apple fanboy, I've used Android before, and I don't have any long-term stake in either operating system. I just wanted to see the presentation and find out what people thought of it. I kinda hoped it would be, to borrow a phrase from a recently departed legend, insanely great.
And all I got were the fanboys. I would guess that most of them are teenagers and very young adults, and all of them are so invested in rooting for one operating system over the other or one phone over anothr that they can't see how they're just rooting for multinational corporations and pieces of technology. There is no point to it. Any innovation that either side, assuming that there are sides to take, comes up with is a win for the public. If Apple comes up with something new, Android will adopt it at some point. If Android comes up with something new, you can be sure that Apple will try to incorporate it into iOS at some point. Either way, everybody wins. And as far as the hardware is concerned, there's a new phone practically every week. Whatever you buy is going to be eclipsed in short order. (One of the good things about buying an iPhone is that if you measure it by just looking at the iPhone universe, you're going to get about a year of being state-of-the-art before a new phone comes out and you want that one)
But, again, there's no reason to choose sides as if this was a schoolyard brawl. If, when I'm ready to buy the next phone, Android phones show a significant technological or usability lead, I'll buy one. Right now, what I saw of Ice Cream Sandwich tonight didn't make me feel jealous at all; It was just another evolutionary step in operating systems. I didn't like the way the screens looked, and I thought that the usability element was a little lacking. If I was in the market for a phone and happens to end up with one of those, I'd be happy, but the iPhone is, for me, right now, just easier to use, even if the latest version isn't that much different from the previous one. Your mileage, of course, may vary, and that's great -- competition is the best thing for consumers, and having a strong Android and a strong iOS (and a strong Windows Phone 7, if that happens) is good for everyone. Choice is good.
But that's not the kind of analysis you see in the comments at the tech blogs. Instead, all you get are people making fun of others for having bought a different phone. Apple fanboys call Android users names, and Android fanboys -- it always seems to be boys -- assert moral superiority over everybody else on earth. For people deeply into tech, they all -- both sides -- come across as immature.
So I came away with less of a clear picture about the new Android OS than I wanted to get. The new features didn't grab me, but I wanted to hear what people thought were the key improvements, because I'm looking to be educated. Instead, all that I got were "iPhone, you got pwned!" and "it's all copying iOS" and "nice clone of Metro." It makes me appreciate the comments we get at Nerdist, where people are, with only a rare exception here and there, civil, enthusiastic, and reasoned, even when they're trying to tell me I'm an idiot. It would be nice to find a tech blog that wasn't overwhelmed by the fanboys, but for now, I'm swearing off the comments.